PoP, originally uploaded by Prince of Petworth.
Ed. Note: I feel like an ass posting this because it is a bit overly complimentary. But when your buddy currently serving in the US Special Forces over in Iraq writes something like this, well, you just gotta post it and all I can say is thank you.
The answer is yes. There can be no doubt of it.
We are through the looking glass, readers; test-driving the gray matter of the adversary. We will leave the questions about the numbers of troops in foreign wars to the lightweights and the options for the future of the Patriot Act to the dilettantes. We, the serious, will consider ways to attack the disease of terrorism instead of fretting about its symptoms.
At its root, the act of terrorism is about desperation. It is a simultaneous cry for recognition and an intimidation attempt; a last resort for people that are deeply committed to a cause and believe there is no recourse. In most cases, those that flock to extremist banners of all types are earnest, vulnerable people that are preyed upon by manipulative masters. These terrorists are often simply pawns in the game. They seek a better world for their family, tribe, sect, race or nation and are made to believe that no peaceful means will accomplish that goal. Living in failed states can contribute to a feeling that no functional forum exists to audit grievances.
What do you know anyway, Interested Onlooker?
Nothing for certain. Just a few hypotheses.
I do have the luxury of a front row seat. As a special operator with 20 months of time down-range, I’ve had more than a few moments to cogitate about the nature of the beast. I should point out that persons of my ilk are “counter-terrorists” and by our very nature, we are reactive. We seek to counter what is believed to be an anti-social and illegal behavior. We have the capability to play defense and offense, but can only act on those that have already joined the game.
The Prince, good reader, is an “anti-terrorist” because his modus operandi defeats the conditions that cause people to become terrorists.
How?
Simple: he provides access to local public officials, visibility on area school systems, detailed information about the places we live and ideas for enjoying free time. He provides us with a voice and a portal to connect to the people and the wider world around us. The Beautiful Life. Options. That puts him in a unique position.
The anti-terrorist doesn’t simply play a perpetual game of whack-a-mole as the counter-terrorist does. The anti-terrorist changes the entire nature of the game. Were this same service to exist in Baghdad (as well as the conditions to support it,) fewer and fewer would convert to the violent subculture.
I, the counter-terrorist, will continue to play my role because I know that the garden will not grow unless it’s weeded first (and frequently,) but I will continue to support the Prince because I know the garden also needs watering and fertilizer.
Count on the PoP to make your world safer in 2009.
Category: Guest Post
COMMENTS
08 February 2012 12:05 PM
COMMENTS
07 February 2012 1:29 PM
COMMENTS
08 February 2012 11:25 AM
COMMENTS
05 February 2012 3:11 PM
COMMENTS
06 February 2012 6:52 PM
Mom AND Dad? Who you kiddin
wamu almost exclusively
WXPN out of Philadelphia. There's not even a close second for music.
+1 just not getting what the hope was of posting this.
Am I the only person who lives in the U Street Area to have a problem with the fact that...
Your buddy is a hell of a writer. Were he to start a blog / book / essay series, I would read them excitedly.
I guess everyone has to feel their job is important, even if it is killing people.
bizarre.
If the soldier thinks, “In most cases, those that flock to extremist banners of all types are earnest, vulnerable people that are preyed upon by manipulative masters. These terrorists are often simply pawns in the game,” I would urge going a little deeper because that’s still a passive observation.
I think he’s making some important distinctions here about simply reacting and getting to root causes. I agree that this site can and does improve information flow among business, gov’t, and the citizenry while maintaining a generally positive outlook and easy vibe. The effect does counter that feeling of disenfranchisement that leads some to act out violently, at least to some degree.
A really interesting post and he’s clearly a good writer. The curt John Wayne-esque declarations undermine the thoughtfulness of other paragraphs. I bet he’s seen and done some crazy stuff, well-worth reading about.
I once met a former Army Ranger who turned into a beach bum in Belize – he’d survived a one-on-one fight to the death with a Republican Guard and he’d been stabbed, shot, and sported a dented skull. Since then, I always want to ask these Special Forces guys if they count how many folks they’ve killed and at what range, since the beach bum said he thought about the guy he killed every day….
Matthew J if you truly believe that all that the US Special Forces job is “killing people” then you are living in as much ignorance as the suicide bomber who believes that by blowing himself up and killing as many other people as he can he is doing Allah’s work.
US Special Forces have contributed to winning more hearts and minds than any politician or diplomat that has stepped foot in Iraq or Afghanistan. Who do you think is actually going to the villages to meet with tribal elders and local leaders creating alliances and instilling trust in them with the goal of keeping the peace?
Not to mention they are the only ones capable of providing enough security in areas that desperately NGOs and the UN to be able to come in and provide basic human needs like clean drinking water, electricity, shelter, food, hospitals and schools.
Don’t believe everything your TV tells you.
Yeah, we’d be a lot better off if all of our overseas-deployed soldiers had the level of training, discipline, and intelligence that the Special Forces do.
Unfortunately, that’s not the case. And there’s no limit to the number of “hearts and minds” that can be un-won by a single scared 18-year-old who doesn’t know the language, doesn’t know the customs, doesn’t know why he’s there, but does know how to shoot.
wow Matthew J- I am by no means a fan of war…but that might be one of the most unintelligent things I’ve ever heard.
What if I just changed a few words:
“At its root, [joining the military] is about desperation. It is a simultaneous cry for recognition and an intimidation attempt; a last resort for people that are deeply committed to a cause and believe there is no recourse. In most cases, those that flock to [military] banners of all types are earnest, vulnerable people that are preyed upon by manipulative masters. These [military personnel] are often simply pawns in the game. They seek a better world for their family, tribe, sect, race or nation and are made to believe that no peaceful means will accomplish that goal.”
Not too far off, ey?
so “clever” Matthew J. You clearly have no idea what you are talking about. Way to show your complete ignorance of the military, foreign policy, and reality in general.
Thankfully, this soldier, along with every soldier, Marine, sailor, and airman, I’ve ever known, does the job for you, regardless of how disapproving you are of them. That’s the difference between us and you. It’s just too bad you will never understand that.
But that’s ok, because we never ask that you understand. In fact we don’t even ask for your thanks. Because we know it’s not about that, and not aobut you or how you feel, but that it is about whether you have the freedom to be you and feel how you feel without the fear that you will be imprisoned or punished for expressing yourself.
Nonetheless, future Pop attorney-this war was illegal. It was and is illegal to invade a sovreign country. An even more detailed analysis of this situation might also include the US Government’s relationship with Saddam Hussein before this war of “liberation” went down. I’m sorry-I am not comfortable with people who don’t question what they do.
The Iraq War was and is illegal.
Matthew J…. fascinating substitution. I do wonder why these earnest young Southern and Western Americans and inner city youth join the military.
But I’m also sad the unwieldy, large size of our population has put such a distance between the members of the military who risk their lives in combat and those who decide where to send troops (e.g decision to get involved in Iraq #2).